Traditional Publishing
Self-Publishing
Share

Why do editors 'ghost'

bukiebooks.substack.com – Saturday January 25, 2025

I saw some recent discourse about this on the Substack app, but it’s been a topic of heated conversation within publishing, between writers and agents, and between agents and editors for the past few years. Some of you may recall Jonathan Karp’s infamous mandate that editors must respond to agent submissions within a month1, after he learned about ghosting.

In the past few years, there have been more instances of editors simply not responding to submissions from agents. They will respond to the pitch, but after receiving the manuscript, neither reject nor ask for a call, even after multiple follow-ups and sometimes even after calls and auction rules are set.

If you are an editor I work with who follows me here, this isn’t about you. You are all perfect. Also, thanks!

Why is this happening?

To read the full article on bukiebooks.substack.com, click here

Share